The no-claims bonus/malus coefficient and the vehicle’s market value are the two factors that have the greatest impact on the cost of car insurance. Reviewing these details before comparing policies helps you avoid taking out cover that is poorly suited to your needs, too expensive or inadequate in the event of a claim.
Excesses and claim limits: what your premium doesn’t tell you
Comparing car insurance policies based solely on the annual premium is a mistake. The excess determines how much you actually have to pay after a claim, and it can vary considerably between insurers, even for policies that appear to offer identical cover.
According to SRA data reported by Rappli, collision repairs cost significantly more in 2025 than in 2021. This steady rise in costs makes claim limits and excesses more important than ever when choosing a policy.
Three areas deserve a thorough review before you sign:
- The excess for accidental damage, expressed as a fixed amount or a percentage of the vehicle’s value, sometimes with a non-negotiable minimum that can make minor claims costly
- The limit on theft cover, which may be capped at the vehicle’s market value at the time of the claim or, under some policies, at the purchase price for a limited period
- The terms of windscreen cover, where the excess can vary threefold depending on whether the windscreen is repaired or replaced
Recycled parts can also affect the actual cost of a claim. In 2025, nearly 21% of repairs approved by an assessor included at least one recycled part, compared with around 12% in 2021, according to the SRA. Checking whether the insurer and its repair network use recycled parts helps you understand what repairs will involve in practice.
A policy with an apparently competitive premium but a high excess and a low limit for property damage can end up costing more after the first significant claim. We recommend simulating a typical claim scenario (a collision with an identified third party, windscreen damage or theft from a public road) to compare the total cost, not just the premium.

Third-party, third-party fire and theft, or comprehensive: choose based on your vehicle’s value
Third-party insurance covers civil liability, meaning damage caused to others. It is the legal minimum. Adding cover for theft, fire and windscreen damage gives you third-party fire and theft cover. Comprehensive insurance also covers damage to you and your vehicle, including when you are at fault.
Comprehensive cover may not be worthwhile for a vehicle with a low market value. For a car over eight years old with a low resale value, a comprehensive premium can account for a disproportionate share of its remaining value. Extended third-party cover (civil liability, theft, fire and natural disasters) may offer better value for money.
By contrast, a new or high-end vehicle calls for comprehensive cover, ideally with an option to reimburse you at the purchase price for the first few years. This type of cover is time-limited, often to two or three years, depending on the policy.
For drivers who are unsure, Auto XP insurance lets you tailor cover to your profile and vehicle, making it easier to strike the right balance between protection and budget.
Electric vehicles: check for specific cover
Electric cars present a distinct insurance challenge. Repairing or replacing the battery can account for a substantial share of the vehicle’s value. Checking the terms of battery cover (whether the battery is owned or leased, the claim limit and any exclusions for natural degradation) is essential before taking out a policy.
An electric vehicle may also be off the road for longer after a claim because of parts shortages or a lack of approved repairers. Replacement vehicle and towing assistance cover deserve particular attention for electric vehicles.
Natural disaster surcharge and rising car insurance premiums
The natural disaster surcharge on car insurance policies rose from 6% to 9% on 1 January 2025. This increase affects all policyholders, including those who have never made a claim. It comes on top of the general rise in repair costs and partly explains why premiums have increased in recent years.
With prices rising across the board, reviewing your policy is more worthwhile than ever.
Here are a few practical ways to keep your premium down without sacrificing cover:
- Choose a higher voluntary excess to reduce your premium, provided you have enough savings to cover a minor claim
- Choose a mileage-based policy if you drive infrequently, as some insurers offer lower rates below a certain annual mileage
- Bundle multiple policies (car and home) with the same insurer to qualify for loyalty discounts, while checking that each policy remains competitive on its own

Switching car insurance: what the law allows
Under the Hamon Law, policyholders can cancel their car insurance at any time, free of charge, after the first year. For policies taken out online, cancellation can be completed directly through the insurer’s customer portal.
Switching insurers each year when your policy no longer meets your needs isn’t a sign of instability; it’s a way to save money. Your new insurer will handle the cancellation with your previous provider.
One thing to keep in mind: when you switch, your statement of information (which records your claims history and no-claims bonus/malus coefficient) must be sent to your new insurer. Any delay or error in this document could result in an incorrect premium. Requesting it from your current insurer before applying elsewhere can help you avoid this problem.
Choosing car insurance is less about comparing advertised premiums than assessing your out-of-pocket costs in the event of a claim, matching the level of cover to your vehicle’s value, and being able to shop around each year.



